Off the Wall

3/10/05 Seminar notes, very rough, not for presentation

Paul Grace and Debbie Besford

PG the proposal signals an idea that space isn't neutral.

Walter Benjamin  core ideas environment is a given, extension on our own nature a symptom of part social forms and power relationships.

Photos align themselves with the spaces in which they appear.

Playtime, 1968.  Jacques Tati director and main character. 

M Hulot has an appointment in Paris, but he gets lost in a maze if modern architecture and bewildering gadgetry. He ends up roaming around the city with a group of tourists. 

Plot is a vehicle for social comments.

1960s architecture models on masters

Angular architecture, people walking in lines and angles, uniforms, hard edge to everything.

Uniformity of the architecture - the opening building could be an airport of a hospital

Individuals showing anxieties - American 'at home wherever I am,'

Architecture determines the way people behave

Tragic undercurrent: spontaneous behaviour banned from the environment

People are co-erced by the space

Space establishes a psychological ..

Beaudillard on the Pompidou centre, materials the arch style, the high culture all deter the behaviour of the old market place it replaced.

Waiting room with photos - didn't look at photos, preoccupied with the furniture. Photos looking down authoritively, men in suits, not to be looked at. Establish a power relationship, to impress, to inform rather than entertain, reinforces power/authority.\

Men in suits have red handerkechiefs

Man gets lost in the maze of the building

Photos are an extension on the space, performing the same fascination as the building, reinforcing authority, power, established hierarchy

Lines of perfect symmetry in the building

    

Modern call centres predicated in the typing pool

Grids and suppresses behaviour

Andra Gerszkey photos of Tokyo stock exchange - huge spaces gridded

Space open an towering photos suggest the visitor is begin observed

Specimen butterfly in the space

The man subverts all this by just being human, natural behaviour contrasts with the robotic jestures of the other characters coping with modernity

Nowadays this surveillance is real

Foucault writes about surveillance in society

Prison - penopticon circular prison all cells visible device for optimum surveillance. person doing the surveillance couldn't be seen so the prisoner never knew if he was being watched, so the viewing gaze is internalised, assume they are being watched all the time. we internalise an imaginary order watching us all the time.

If we aren't watching you, God is

The architectural environment and the photos which support that have a huge impact on our behaviour in society

Geometry has massive effects on us

Places the viewer in a situation of subjection - arch and photos combine

Is it possible to photo without placing the viewer in a  position of subjection?

Dismi piece green sheet

The Child absorbs information does the environment produce a certain way of thinking? the social codes are enshrined in our architecture

Physical structures affect mental structures

(so what about mixed architectural environments?)

Wendy Ewell (MTH)

People whose photographic work disrupts this alignment between geometry and the environment

Helen Chadwick uses photos in her artwork

ego geometricum sum  I am geometry

spaces tents, pyramids come across in life prams

covers surfaces with photographic emulsion

struggle between the body and the geometrical form

 

Peter Halley

American painter addresses issues

Large scale abstract paintings

Social criticism implicit

work triggered by Foucault (surveillance, punishment) all paintings are or cells

Individualisation, restriction, isolated from the world

Cells connected by conduits cf real life

1980s/90s

Later work is more complex as he addresses modern communication like the web

Sometimes the conduits take over from the cells

 

Gordon Matta Clarke

Architect trained

Takes over abandoned or derelict buildings, works with a chain saw and pneumatic drills to cut away at the existing architecture in a   symbolic act, aware of how the architectural environment in the manifestation of a confining force.

 

A tunnel, drilled through a tenement block next to the Pompidou centre so that the new could be seen though the old

 

Debbie Besford

own work done a while ago

who is the audience? what happens when the work is passed to a third party eg a magazine?

Children with polio is Dares Salam

spent a month not taking images, only in the last week, in order to avoid the sensational

work went on tour - the building and environment affected the reception of the work

N&N new life project

photos in the home and hospital

midwives' hands

quotes on perspex interspersed between the images, also on the back of postcards.

DB had to work on trust with the women, they needed to know how the images were being used.

Wellcome institute: the art and science of life in the womb 1999

The meaning changes once the photo leaves the control of the author and is used by a third party

URLs

(All accessed and working 20/11/05)

French Culture.org Cultural Services of the French Embassy

Debby Besford

Wellcome Institute

(C) Helen Williams 2005